⚠ Switch to EXCALIDRAW VIEW in the MORE OPTIONS menu of this document. ⚠ You can decompress Drawing data with the command palette: ‘Decompress current Excalidraw file’. For more info check in plugin settings under ‘Saving’

Excalidraw Data

Text Elements

More likely to be directive with respect to the nature of the views or claims made; it may be challenging to identify when it is appropriate to be directive

Is the issue one in which the disagreement rests on some views being inconsistent with liberal society? (Political criterion) E.g., views encompassing hate speech

Yes

No

More likely to be non-directive with less focus on epistemic issues (e.g., debates around free speech vs privacy)

Is the disagreement something people commonly disagree on in public society? (Behavioural criterion)

Is it a disagreement that is commonly known about (i.e., many people are aware people disagree on it)?

Is it a common disagreement (i.e., many people have differing views)?

Pedagogically productive, with possible directive strategies for sharing of common ideals for assessing credibility / evidence, but may be non-directive regarding particular beliefs or claims.

Be cautious selecting issues for non-directive teaching, as this may result in false balance/both side-ism, and focusing on niche (possibly widely known) views, such as climate denialism or unfounded conspiracy theories

Well known disagreements may result in downplaying marginalised views, or ignoring issues or their impacts that have unequal effects (e.g., neglect of voices of those with disabilities in discussion of social support; or cases in which a burden is placed on impacted people such as in discussion of equal marriage rights)

Is the issue something on which there are multiple perspectives that are rationally defensible (i.e., based in evidence)? (Epistemic criterion)