::: title Learning to Navigate Uncertainty, Disagreement, and Evidence: Workshop 01 :::

notes:

Workshop structure:

  1. Shared language
  2. Diverse approaches
  3. Paths forward

::: title hello world :::

::: mermaid


flowchart TB



classDef blankNode fill:transparent,stroke:transparent

classDef greyNode fill:#767676,stroke:transparent

subgraph Three criteria for controversial issues

subgraph Types of criteria

behavioural["`Behavioural criterion: Is the issue something many people disagree on in public society?`"]

political["`Political criterion: Are the issues at stake compatible with values of liberal democracy? (i.e., does the controversy rest on some views being illiberal)`"]

epistemic["`Epistemic criterion: Are there multiple perspectives on the issue that are rationally defensible (i.e., based in evidence)`"]

behavioural--->fringe["`Be cautious about selecting issues based on broad disagreement; this may result in focusing on niche views (albeit they may be widely known), such as climate denialism`"]

behavioural--->marginalization["`Conversely, focus on widely acknowledge disagreement may result in further marginalisation (ignoring marginalised views, or ignoring issues whose impacts are not equally spread), such as neglect of people with disabilities in issues with an accessibility concern, or cass in which a burden is placed on impacted people such as in discussion of equal marriage rights`"]

political--->politicalyes["`If an issue includes views that conflict with liberal values, a directive teaching approach may be adopted.`"]
political--->paradox["`Thinking of controversy in terms of liberal values presents challenges, in part because of a 'paradox of liberalism', that liberal society accepts illiberal ideas/ideals rendering them consistent with living in such a society albeit not always with liberal ideals. The criterion is thus challenging to apply. It may be useful in considering moral questions (e.g., free speech vs privacy), in which an epistemic criterion (i.e., rational argument) may be harder to frame.`"]
political--->politicalno["`If an issue does not conflict with liberal values, a non-directive teaching approach may be appropriate.`"]



epistemic--->best["`Framing controversy in terms of multiple defensible, evidenced, perspectives is likely the strongest approach, for example, discussion of approaches to mitigate climate change.`"]

end
end

:::