⚠ Switch to EXCALIDRAW VIEW in the MORE OPTIONS menu of this document. ⚠ You can decompress Drawing data with the command palette: ‘Decompress current Excalidraw file’. For more info check in plugin settings under ‘Saving’

Excalidraw Data

Text Elements

Domain / disciplinary epistemic norms and practices; shaping and shaped by epistemic environment and epistemic in/justice

Epistemic aims (what we want to know and why) and ideals (how we assess claims of knowing)

More or less apt epistemic performance

Sociocultural factors

Individual and joint cognition

Epistemic processes, products, and standards

Motivation, affect, and epistemic emotions

Epistemic friendliness/ hostility of epistemic environment, and treatment of epistemic vice / virtue

Epistemic interests, aims, emotions, and dispositions

Seen in context of tasks

Metacogniton - Thinking about one’s own or one’s group’s thinking processes and strategies

Deploy epistemic metacognitive knowledge and skills such as argumentation, source evaluation, value judgements, inference, collecting data, identifying claims and assumptions

“epistemic metacognitive experiences, which involve feelings and estimates [e.g., sense of certainty] that are evoked by knowledge building and justification processes and that are related to the nature of knowledge and knowing.”

“epistemic metacognitive skills for planning, monitoring, and evaluating epistemic processes and strategies;”

Identify goals in context of task, and experience of the task

Plan with respect to goals and their epistemic ideals (i.e., standards)

Use epistemic metacognitive knowledge and strategies to address goals

Develop and evaluate products against goals

Monitor against goals using knowledge of e.g., epistemic aims and ideals

Monitor against goals with respect to task experiences (e.g., ambiguity tolerance, need for cognition, etc. )

This work is licensed under CC BY 4.0

https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/?ref=chooser-v1

Knight, S. (2024). Relationships of epistemic cognition to other constructs. https://sjgknight.com/DECRA/

https://sjgknight.com/DECRA/

Quoted text is drawn from: Barzilai and Chinn (2018) discussion of Barzilai and Zohar (2014, 2016).

https://sjgknight.com/DECRA/zotero/barzilaiReconsideringPersonalEpistemology2014a

Simplified task: “Evaluate two accounts of this phenomenon or event stating which is more likely”

Individual considers epistemic status of the particular claims or/and sources the two accounts provide

Identifies goal (to evaluate accounts), in light of prior attitude and affective response to the accounts or/and sources (e.g., if one account is more consistent with prior beliefs, or from a known trusted source)

Use epistemic metacognitive knowledge and skills to identify appropriate ideals and processes to (1) evaluate the claims against and (2) develop an appropriate conclusion; influenced by metacognitive experiences e.g., relating to weighing of ‘likely’ outcomes and tolerance of uncertainty and ambiguity.

Deploy metacognitive knowledge and strategies, e.g., by evaluating the two sources, analysing the arguments made and their use of data, assessing their stance or underlying values.

Develop output that provides an evaluation of the two accounts and statement of which is more likely; evaluated iteratively as described above

CEEP

MSREP

“epistemic metacognitive knowledge regarding the nature of knowledge and knowing” E.g., one’s knowledge about appropriate justification of aims and ideals, selection of reliable processes based on aims and ideals, etc. (i.e., epistemic meta-discourse/practice)

MEK

Epistemic cognition “cognitive epistemic processes and strategies for thinking and reasoning about the epistemic status and properties of specific information, claims, and sources”. Epistemic discourse / practices. E.g., evaluating a particular claim or source is at the cognitive level.

MEE

MEMK

Construct

How construct applies to thinking

CEEP

MEMK

Task context: A contested historical event, in which understanding source context is important for understanding disciplinary evaluation strategies, and how historical narrative has emerged.

MEK

MSREP

MEE

Embedded Files

598b5d9203054976d4857791299e97e3ac321ea5: Pasted Image 20241030123737_685.svg

41c1b57a36901487fd3f4c28ede52d839fe33400: Pasted Image 20241030123737_653.svg