⚠ Switch to EXCALIDRAW VIEW in the MORE OPTIONS menu of this document. ⚠ You can decompress Drawing data with the command palette: ‘Decompress current Excalidraw file’. For more info check in plugin settings under ‘Saving’
Excalidraw Data
Text Elements
Closing
Non-directive
Non-directive approach risks acquisitional injustice where e.g., we are not directive about issues or approaches of consequence (e.g., vaccine safety) or fall into naïve relativism. If non-dominant perspectives are not built into (closing) tasks, consideration may be superficial.
Opening
Non-directive approach May provide opportunity for skills development and sharing of experiences (contributory justices).
Directive
Directive approaches provide opportunity for acquisitional justice where (a) credibility assessment is an important feature (albeit only one); and (b) authoritativeness is important for content reasons
Directive approaches may limit opportunity to contribute or to explore reliable processes outside ‘authority’ as a focus of instruction related to credibility assessment, relating to contributory injustice.
Benefit
Risk
Benefit
Risk
Directive
Directive approaches provide opportunity for testimonial and acquisitional justice where they provide space for voices.
Directive approaches may result in testimonial and contributory injustices arising from being directed towards a particular perspective or approach (even where others are considered).
Non-directive
Non-directive approach may risk testimonial injustices where e.g., tasks allow learners to opt not to engage with knowledge/ knowers. Hermenutical injustices may hinder engagement due to lack of interpretative resource without guidance.
Non-directive approach May provide opportunity for skills development and sharing of experiences (contributory justices).
Closing: Learning oriented around canon of knowledge with directive or non-directive approaches. Stimuli or/and process scaffolds provide limited scope for engagement with non-dominant knowledge.
Opening: Learning oriented around broader knowledge in content and approach (e.g., critique). Stimuli or/and process scaffolds either directly provide non-dominant perspectives, or/and encourage exploration of these.
E.g., task involving review of established theory with recommendations made from this, with direction towards particular theory or method of evaluation.
E.g., task involving review of established theory with recommendations made from this, in which students must identify their view on the best approach or/and method of evaluation for establishing such an approach.
E.g., task involving review of established theory with recommendations made from this, in which students must identify their view on the best approach or/and method of evaluation for establishing such an approach. The task either explicitly encourages, or leaves open potential for, engagement with non-dominant approaches.
E.g., task involving review of established theory with recommendations made from this. The task either explicitly encourages, or leaves open potential for, engagement with non-dominant approaches, providing direction towards particularly perspectives or approaches.
Non-directive
Non-directive approach risks acquisitional injustice where e.g., we are not directive about issues or approaches of consequence (e.g., vaccine safety) or fall into naïve relativism. If non-dominant perspectives are not built into (closing) tasks, their consideration may be superficial.
Closing
Opening
Non-directive approach May provide opportunity for skills development and sharing of experiences (contributory justices).
Directive approaches provide opportunity for acquisitional justice where (a) credibility assessment is an important feature (albeit only one); and (b) authoritativeness is important for content reasons
Directive approaches may limit opportunity to contribute or to explore reliable processes outside ‘authority’ as a focus of instruction related to credibility assessment, relating to contributory injustice.
Benefit
Risk
Benefit
Risk
Directive
Directive approaches provide opportunity for testimonial and acquisitional justice where they provide space for voices via direction to sources or/and methods.
Directive approaches may result in testimonial and contributory injustices arising from being directed towards a particular perspective or approach (even where others are considered).
Non-directive approach may risk testimonial injustices where e.g., tasks allow learners to opt not to engage with knowledge/ knowers. Hermenutical injustices may hinder engagement due to lack of interpretative resource without guidance.
Non-directive approach May provide opportunity for skills development and sharing of experiences (contributory justices).
Closing: Learning oriented around canon of knowledge with directive or non-directive approaches. Stimuli or/and process scaffolds provide limited scope for engagement with non-dominant knowledge.
Opening: Learning oriented around broader knowledge in content and approach (e.g., critique). Stimuli or/and process scaffolds either directly provide non-dominant perspectives, or/and encourage exploration of these.
E.g.,…atudents must identify their view on the best approach or/and method of evaluation for establishing such an approach. .
E.g., task providesdirection towards particularly perspectives or approaches.
The task either explicitly encourages, or leaves open potential for, engagement with non-dominant approaches.
E.g., task involving review of established theory with recommendations made from this.
Benefit
Benefit
Risk
Risk